| Name | School | State | State | # of Entries | |
| Morales | Johns Hopkins | AZ | PA | 25 | |
| Pestano | Central | CA | NJ | 24 | |
| Lawson | Elmhurst | CA | NY | 18 | |
| Kelly | Loras | CA | OH | 18 | |
| Hewson | Cornell | CO | IL | 15 | |
| Gonzalez | Johnson & Wales | CT | IA | 14 | |
| Thomas | Johnson & Wales | CT | WI | 12 | |
| Shay | Roger Williams | CT | CT | 8 | |
| Cannone | Wartburg | CT | MN | 8 | |
| Ross | Wartburg | CT | IN | 6 | |
| Bylykbashi | Washington & Lee | CT | MA | 5 | |
| Bellamy | Wesleyan | CT | VA | 4 | |
| Carrillo | Wesleyan | CT | CA | 3 | |
| Gould | Augustana | IA | MD | 3 | |
| Fritz | Central | IA | MI | 3 | |
| Erickson | Coe | IA | TX | 3 | |
| Holladay | Coe | IA | LA | 2 | |
| Voss | Coe | IA | ME | 2 | |
| Nevills | La Crosse | IA | RI | 2 | |
| Birt | Millikin | IA | WA | 2 | |
| DeVos | Wartburg | IA | AZ | 1 | |
| Doebel | Wartburg | IA | CO | 1 | |
| Evans | Wartburg | IA | OK | 1 | |
| Fank | Wartburg | IA | |||
| Lutes | Wartburg | IA | |||
| Rathbun | Wartburg | IA | |||
| Thomsen | Wartburg | IA | |||
| Giatras | Augustana | IL | |||
| Remke | Coast Guard | IL | |||
| Martin | Cornell | IL | |||
| Ortmann | Cornell | IL | |||
| Demo | Eau Claire | IL | |||
| McAuliffe | Elmhurst | IL | |||
| Munoz | Elmhurst | IL | |||
| Davis | Loras | IL | |||
| Jennings | Millikin | IL | |||
| Williams | Millikin | IL | |||
| Berta | North Central | IL | |||
| Johnson | Platteville | IL | |||
| Fuentez | Wheaton | IL | |||
| Bonomo | Whitewater | IL | |||
| Tortorice | Whitewater | IL | |||
| Wilson | Manchester | IN | |||
| Bates | Wabash | IN | |||
| Bethel | Wabash | IN | |||
| Doster | Wabash | IN | |||
| Hatch | Wabash | IN | |||
| Schurg | Wabash | IN | |||
| Gilliam | Loras | LA | |||
| Patron | Loras | LA | |||
| O’Brien | Ithaca | MA | |||
| Settles | New England | MA | |||
| Humphries | Roger Williams | MA | |||
| Fusco | Springfield | MA | |||
| Boyle | Western New England | MA | |||
| Kowalski | Gettysburg | MD | |||
| Reyes | Johns Hopkins | MD | |||
| Burrs | Waynesburg | MD | |||
| Del Gallo | Southern Maine | ME | |||
| Shorey | Southern Maine | ME | |||
| Ladd | Alma | MI | |||
| Hammack | Heidelberg | MI | |||
| Grimsley | Olivet | MI | |||
| Bennyhoff | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Epps | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Flynn | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Gliva | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Jeske | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Vassar | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Wilson | Augsburg | MN | |||
| Newman | Whitewater | MN | |||
| Muce | Centenary | NJ | |||
| Udott | Centenary | NJ | |||
| McClave | Coast Guard | NJ | |||
| Ghione | Elizabethtown | NJ | |||
| Tolbert | Ferrum | NJ | |||
| Brisman | Ithaca | NJ | |||
| Mase | Ithaca | NJ | |||
| Velez | Ithaca | NJ | |||
| Ferinde | Johnson & Wales | NJ | |||
| Redington | Messiah | NJ | |||
| Drill | NYU | NJ | |||
| Jazikoff | NYU | NJ | |||
| Lyons | NYU | NJ | |||
| Noble | NYU | NJ | |||
| Sisco | Oneonta | NJ | |||
| Cutugno | RIT | NJ | |||
| Gazaway | Roger Williams | NJ | |||
| Poklikuha | Stevens | NJ | |||
| Stanich | Stevens | NJ | |||
| Van Sickell | Stevens | NJ | |||
| Wilhelm | Stevens | NJ | |||
| Kilroy | TCNJ | NJ | |||
| Seyfried | Williams | NJ | |||
| Sindoni | York | NJ | |||
| Engle | Brockport | NY | |||
| Haas | Brockport | NY | |||
| Peacock | Brockport | NY | |||
| Aeberli | Coast Guard | NY | |||
| Antoine | Cortland | NY | |||
| Chery | Cortland | NY | |||
| Espinal | Cortland | NY | |||
| Zupan | Cortland | NY | |||
| Ashcraft | Ithaca | NY | |||
| Colom | Ithaca | NY | |||
| White | Ithaca | NY | |||
| Albis | Johnson & Wales | NY | |||
| DiNardo | Johnson & Wales | NY | |||
| Bethel | Oneonta | NY | |||
| Seymour | Oswego | NY | |||
| Calkins | RIT | NY | |||
| Barbaria | Roger Williams | NY | |||
| Pirraglia | Wesleyan | NY | |||
| Arroyo | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Bleich | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Doyle | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Ginnetti | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Lehman | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Maclellan | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Mahaney | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Nash | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Ransom | Baldwin Wallace | OH | |||
| Dixon | John Carroll | OH | |||
| Lasko | John Carroll | OH | |||
| Hojnacki | Messiah | OH | |||
| James | Mount Union | OH | |||
| Mancini | Mount Union | OH | |||
| McIntire | Mount Union | OH | |||
| Wochna | Mount Union | OH | |||
| Nelson | Ohio Northern | OH | |||
| Kasper | Otterbein | OH | |||
| Sorensen | Trinity | OK | |||
| Wagner | Coast Guard | PA | |||
| Ambacher | Delaware Valley | PA | |||
| Rush | Delaware Valley | PA | |||
| Cavallo | Johns Hopkins | PA | |||
| Conrad | Lycoming | PA | |||
| Corl | Lycoming | PA | |||
| Wesneski | Lycoming | PA | |||
| Beitz | Messiah | PA | |||
| Edwards | Messiah | PA | |||
| Harris | Messiah | PA | |||
| Koser | Messiah | PA | |||
| Maloney | Messiah | PA | |||
| Swarr | Messiah | PA | |||
| Barcaskey | Ohio Northern | PA | |||
| Winters | RIT | PA | |||
| Kaliner | Stevens | PA | |||
| Buxton | Waynesburg | PA | |||
| Evans | Waynesburg | PA | |||
| Grossmann | Wilkes | PA | |||
| Marsh | WPI | PA | |||
| Alic | York | PA | |||
| Hutchinson | York | PA | |||
| Krauss | York | PA | |||
| Nuttal | York | PA | |||
| Warner | York | PA | |||
| Aurelio | Johnson & Wales | RI | |||
| Vicente | Johnson & Wales | RI | |||
| Bunce | Merchant Marine | TX | |||
| Jackson | Ozarks | TX | |||
| Rankin | Ozarks | TX | |||
| Velez | Delaware Valley | VA | |||
| Leary | Ferrum | VA | |||
| Matthews | Ferrum | VA | |||
| Aiello | Wheaton | VA | |||
| Vester | Central | WA | |||
| Ramirez | Southern Virginia | WA | |||
| Bloy | Eau Claire | WI | |||
| Vosters | Eau Claire | WI | |||
| Ernst | La Crosse | WI | |||
| Massie | La Crosse | WI | |||
| Schlough | La Crosse | WI | |||
| Schultz | La Crosse | WI | |||
| Bellile | MSOE | WI | |||
| Choinski | Oshkosh | WI | |||
| Goetz | Platteville | WI | |||
| Wedepohl | Platteville | WI | |||
| Diebitz | Stevens Point | WI | |||
| Squires | Stevens Point | WI |
