Here are the class years, as listed on the roster, for each of the 80 All-Americans. If a wrestler was listed as a grad student or 5th year, he was marked down as a senior. This is not an accurate representation of eligibility year, since last year did not count due to COVID. There are seniors on this list that have eligibility remaining and could return next season.
Freshmen: 5
Sophomores: 14
Juniors: 26
Seniors/Grad Students: 35
| Place | Name | Team | Class |
| 6th | Cooper Pontelandolfo | New York | Fr |
| 3rd | Jacob Reed | Ohio Northern | Fr |
| 8th | Michael Conklin | TCNJ | Fr |
| 8th | Darian Estevez | University Of Chicago | Fr |
| 6th | Charles Baczek | Wabash | Fr |
| 5th | Matt Lackman | Alvernia | So |
| 2nd | Michael Petrella | Baldwin Wallace | So |
| 8th | James Rodriguez | Castleton | So |
| 5th | Coy Spooner | Coast Guard | So |
| 4th | Will Esmoil | Coe | So |
| 5th | Josh Wilson | Greensboro | So |
| 7th | Gable Crebs | Lycoming | So |
| 4th | Alex Villar | North Central | So |
| 6th | Robby Bates | North Central | So |
| 7th | Kyle Merritt | Norwich | So |
| 2nd | Donovan King | Olivet | So |
| 7th | Seth Brossard | UW-La Crosse | So |
| 4th | Zane Mulder | Wartburg | So |
| 8th | Joe Pins | Wartburg | So |
| 3rd | Tyler Shilson | Augsburg | Jr |
| 4th | Tyler Kim | Augsburg | Jr |
| 6th | Bentley Schwanebeck-Ostermann | Augsburg | Jr |
| 1st | Jacob Decatur | Baldwin Wallace | Jr |
| 2nd | Andrew Perelka | John Carroll | Jr |
| 7th | Luke Reicosky | John Carroll | Jr |
| 4th | Shane Liegel | Loras | Jr |
| 7th | John Fulmer | Lycoming | Jr |
| 8th | Tommy Russell | Millikin | Jr |
| 1st | Cornell Beachem | Mount St. Joseph | Jr |
| 1st | Robbie Precin | North Central | Jr |
| 1st | Nathan Lackman | Rhode Island College | Jr |
| 8th | Austin Lamb | RIT | Jr |
| 7th | Mahlic Sallah | Roanoke | Jr |
| 4th | Kyle Slendorn | Stevens | Jr |
| 7th | Stefan Major | Stevens | Jr |
| 6th | Ryan Fleck | University Of Chicago | Jr |
| 5th | Nolan Hertel | UW-La Crosse | Jr |
| 3rd | Beau Yineman | UW-Oshkosh | Jr |
| 7th | Zach Thompson | UW-Platteville | Jr |
| 2nd | Jack Heldt | Wabash | Jr |
| 2nd | Zayren Terukina | Wartburg | Jr |
| 5th | Kristian Rumph | Wartburg | Jr |
| 6th | David Hollingsworth | Wartburg | Jr |
| 4th | Ryan Luth | Washington & Lee | Jr |
| 6th | Riley Parker | Washington & Lee | Jr |
| 5th | Solomon Nielsen | Augsburg | Sr |
| 4th | Samuel Braswell | Averett | Sr |
| 6th | Brandon Woody | Averett | Sr |
| 3rd | Shandon Akeo | Central | Sr |
| 2nd | Paul Detwiler | Coast Guard | Sr |
| 3rd | Kaleb Reeves | Coe | Sr |
| 8th | Demitreus Henry | Cortland | Sr |
| 5th | Jimmy McAuliffe | Elmhurst | Sr |
| 5th | Chibueze Chukwuezi | Ithaca | Sr |
| 8th | Jordan Wallace | Ithaca | Sr |
| 8th | Hank Behaeghel | Johns Hopkins | Sr |
| 2nd | Michael Ross | Johnson & Wales | Sr |
| 3rd | Jacob Krakow | Loras | Sr |
| 7th | Josiah Gehr | Messiah | Sr |
| 1st | Bradan Birt | Millikin | Sr |
| 1st | Jordin James | Mount Union | Sr |
| 6th | David Massey | Mount Union | Sr |
| 1st | Cody Baldridge | North Central | Sr |
| 2nd | Kaidon Winters | RIT | Sr |
| 6th | Zach Stedeford | RIT | Sr |
| 5th | Nico Ramirez | Southern Virginia | Sr |
| 1st | Brett Kaliner | Stevens | Sr |
| 8th | Daniel Surich | TCNJ | Sr |
| 3rd | Chase Schmidt | UW-Eau Claire | Sr |
| 1st | Jordan Lemcke | UW-Oshkosh | Sr |
| 4th | Matt Berlin | UW-Stevens Point | Sr |
| 1st | Jaritt Shinhoster | UW-Whitewater | Sr |
| 2nd | Carlos Champagne | Wabash | Sr |
| 2nd | Kyle Hatch | Wabash | Sr |
| 3rd | Alex Barr | Wabash | Sr |
| 3rd | Kyle Briggs | Wartburg | Sr |
| 5th | Brady Kyner | Wartburg | Sr |
| 7th | Nicholas Arborio | Western New England | Sr |
| 3rd | Dalton Rohrbaugh | York | Sr |
| 4th | Camden Farrow | York | Sr |
