2016 All-Americans and Regional Performance
Region Performance
| Region | All-Americans | Team Points | Champions |
| Central | 21 | 283.5 | 2 |
| Mideast | 16 | 224 | 2 |
| Midwest | 15 | 213 | 3 |
| East | 11 | 141.5 | 1 |
| Northeast | 10 | 123 | 2 |
| West | 7 | 84 | 0 |
Four Year Totals 2013-2016 (since the regional system was in place)
| Region | All-Americans | % of total AA | Team Points | % of total Points |
| Central | 67 | 20.94 | 895 | 20.96 |
| East | 52 | 16.25 | 684 | 16.02 |
| Midwest | 65 | 20.31 | 888 | 20.80 |
| Mideast | 56 | 17.5 | 727.5 | 17.04 |
| Northeast | 49 | 15.31 | 612 | 14.33 |
| West | 31 | 9.69 | 463 | 10.84 |
2016 All-Americans (unseeded in italics; 24 total)
| 125 | 165 | ||||
| 1 | Malmberg | Messiah | 1 | Hermsen | Stevens Point |
| 2 | Pestano | Central | 2 | Michael | Wartburg |
| 3 | Spearman | Wash. & Jeff. | 3 | Barger | Lycoming |
| 4 | Denny | Whitewater | 4 | Navickas | Stevens |
| 5 | Olea | Wartburg | 5 | Hensel | Augsburg |
| 6 | Stageberg | ConcordiaMoorhead | 6 | Hojnacki | Messiah |
| 7 | Kaishian | Ithaca | 7 | Velez | Ithaca |
| 8 | Rosenberg | Coe | 8 | Sewera | Coe |
| 133 | 174 | ||||
| 1 | Broukal | Wabash | 1 | Swarr | Messiah |
| 2 | Pike | NYU | 2 | Devos | Wartburg |
| 3 | Weinmann | La Crosse | 3 | Harrington | Coe |
| 4 | O’Boyle | McDaniel | 4 | Schneider | La Crosse |
| 5 | Gunter | Baldwin Wallace | 5 | Blanco | Wash. & Jeff. |
| 6 | Opelt | Cornell | 6 | Sibblies | Centenary |
| 7 | Campo | Wartburg | 7 | Beaman | St. Olaf |
| 8 | Riley | Alma | 8 | Hamann | TCNJ |
| 141 | 184 | ||||
| 1 | Van Anrooy | Luther | 1 | Lefever | Wabash |
| 2 | Nehls | Elmhurst | 2 | Thomson | Messiah |
| 3 | Behnke | Eau Claire | 3 | Kowal | Stevens |
| 4 | Kihn | Heidelberg | 4 | Kreiter | Luther |
| 5 | Warner | York | 5 | Toribio | Ithaca |
| 6 | Williams | Millikin | 6 | Cook | La Crosse |
| 7 | Border | Mount Union | 7 | Conrad | Rhode Island |
| 8 | Giblin | Rhode Island | 8 | Palmeri | Brockport |
| 149 | 197 | ||||
| 1 | Martin | Wartburg | 1 | Welch | Roger Williams |
| 2 | Engle | Cornell | 2 | Roman | Wartburg |
| 3 | Mirman | John Carroll | 3 | Giaramita | Cortland |
| 4 | Lansberry | Lycoming | 4 | Arthur | Adrian |
| 5 | Santi | Elmhurst | 5 | Jakes | Alma |
| 6 | Gray | Luther | 6 | Fisher | Merchant Marine |
| 7 | Kennedy | Augsburg | 7 | Swider | Wheaton |
| 8 | Gaccione | Johnson & Wales | 8 | Watson | Loras |
| 157 | 285 | ||||
| 1 | Dierna | Cortland | 1 | Roseberry | Delaware Valley |
| 2 | Wagenhoffer | Wartburg | 2 | Longendyke | Augsburg |
| 3 | Lopez | Williams | 3 | Evans | Wartburg |
| 4 | Cannon | Messiah | 4 | Maresh | Alma |
| 5 | Zurfluh | Luther | 5 | Triandafilou | Gettysburg |
| 6 | Meister | Ferrum | 6 | Wright | Messiah |
| 7 | Parker | Augsburg | 7 | Maher | Stevens |
| 8 | Bova | Wabash | 8 | Herman | Luther |