The 2024 d3wrestle.com All-Freshman Team is made up of Division III wrestlers who qualified for the NCAA Championships and also were in high school during the 2022-2023 season. Please leave a comment if a wrestler was missed or misidentified. The Freshman of the Year will be named later from this group.
2024 Freshman All-American
Max Borton, Ursinus College, 8th at 184
2024 Freshman NCAA Qualifiers
| 125 | Matt Griffin | TCNJ |
| 133 | Chance Suddeth | Augsburg |
| 141 | Gabe Goss | Oswego State |
| 149 | Taylor Smith | Washington & Jefferson |
| 149 | Ty Koedam | Coe |
| 157 | Jermaine Butler | UW-Whitewater |
| 165 | Andrew Supers | Baldwin Wallace |
| 174 | Xavier Preston | Roanoke |
| 197 | Demond Harrison | Albion |
| 197 | Lorenzo Pellot | Roanoke |
